Virtual laboratory/Mathematics/Number theory/Transcendental numbers — π and e

Transcendental numbers — π and e

An extension of the topic of real numbers and polynomials. Algebraic numbers are roots of polynomials with rational coefficients (e.g. √2 → x²−2=0), whereas transcendental numbers (such as π, e) are not a root of any such polynomial. The transcendence of e was proved by Hermite (1873) and of π by Lindemann (1882). Transcendental numbers are “incomparably more numerous” than algebraic ones.

Transcendental numbers — π and e
Mathematics · Number theory · Transcendental numbers — π and e (1882)
Which number do you want to examine?
Is π\pi a root of some polynomial with rational coefficients?
number examined
½
value
0.5000
root of a rational poly?
Yes
class
algebraic
🎯 Challenge: algebraic or transcendental?
streak: 0

I will give you a number — decide whether it is algebraic (a root of a rational polynomial) or transcendental.

What just happened?

Real numbers split into two classes. An algebraic number is one that is a root of some nonzero polynomial with rational (integer) coefficients. This class includes all rational numbers — e.g. 12\tfrac12 is a root of the equation 2x−1=02x - 1 = 0 — as well as some irrational numbers, such as 2\sqrt2, 75\sqrt[5]{7} or the golden ratio φ\varphi. A transcendental number is one that is NOT a root of any such polynomial — it “transcends” algebra, hence the name.

√2 is algebraic — it is a root of a rational polynomial:

x2−2=0⟹(2)2−2=0x^2 - 2 = 0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad \left(\sqrt2\right)^2 - 2 = 0

Although 2\sqrt2 is irrational, it “closes up” under an equation — which is why it counts as an algebraic number. Likewise 12\tfrac12 satisfies 2x−1=02x - 1 = 0.

π and e are transcendental — no rational polynomial hits them:

∀ p∈Q[x],  p≠0:p(π)≠0   and   p(e)≠0\forall\, p \in \mathbb{Q}[x],\; p \neq 0:\qquad p(\pi) \neq 0 \;\text{ and }\; p(e) \neq 0

Proving that a specific number is transcendental is very hard. Charles Hermite was the first to show the transcendence of ee (1873), and Ferdinand von Lindemann the transcendence of π\pi (1882) — which incidentally settled the ancient problem of squaring the circle: it is impossible with compass and straightedge precisely because π\pi is transcendental.

A surprising proportion:

Georg Cantor showed that there are only countably many algebraic numbers (cardinality ℵ0\aleph_0), but uncountably many real numbers (cardinality continuum c>ℵ0\mathfrak{c} > \aleph_0). Since the algebraic ones are “few” and the reals “incomparably more numerous”, almost every real number is transcendental — even though we know surprisingly few explicit examples.

Why this matters for your exams:

Distinguishing rational, irrational-algebraic and transcendental numbers organises the world of real numbers and recurs in problems about irrationality proofs, about roots of polynomials, and about what cannot be constructed with compass and straightedge (such as squaring the circle).

Remember: a number is algebraic when it is a root of some polynomial with rational coefficients (like 2\sqrt2 for x2−2x^2-2), and transcendental when it is a root of none (like ee and π\pi). Transcendentals are incomparably more numerous.

Illustrative model · NexTutor Virtual Laboratory

Enjoyed the experiment? Share it.

It's free — send it to friends from school.

Theory & formulas

Algebraic vs transcendental

An algebraic number is a root of some polynomial with rational coefficients, e.g. 2\sqrt2 satisfies x2−2=0x^2-2=0. A transcendental number is not a root of any such polynomial.

Examples

ee and π\pi are transcendental — proofs: Hermite (1873) for ee, Lindemann (1882) for π\pi.

How many are there

There are countably many algebraic numbers, but uncountably many reals in total — so transcendental numbers are “incomparably more numerous” (almost every number is transcendental).

Notation: xx the unknown of the polynomial, π≈3.14\pi\approx 3.14, e≈2.72e\approx 2.72.

Frequently asked questions

›

Is π a root of any rational polynomial?

No — π is a transcendental number, it “escapes” all of algebra.

›

How does an algebraic number differ from a transcendental one?

An algebraic number is a root of a polynomial with rational coefficients (e.g. √2); a transcendental number is a root of none.

›

Which numbers are more numerous: algebraic or transcendental?

Transcendental ones — algebraic numbers are countable, while transcendental ones are uncountable (almost every number is transcendental).

Teaching? Embed this experiment on your site.

Free widget — paste it on your school site, blog or notes. It links to the full version.

Teaching a class or tutoring? Guide students in NexTutor →